When Love Is Not Enough

Sometimes love alone cannot heal the deepest of wounds. Jeannine Moga, today's guest blogger, has shared her life with many animals, some of whom came into her life with the tell-tale signs of suffering from trauma. Many of us who have rescued animals can relate to Jeannine's experiences and sentiment that sometimes love is not enough to help the animals who cross our paths.
When Love Is Not Enough
By Jeannine Moga
There was a time when I thought that love and effort could right any wrong, could heal any hurt, could mend that which was broken. That was before I welcomed a severely traumatized animal into my home. I learned the hard way that love is not enough.
Modern life is arguably traumatic. Humans subject one another to countless forms of horror and it seems that we are over-exposed, on a daily basis, to images that shock and violate our sense of security. Sometimes the images that are most horrifying are those involving innocent victims – children and animals – who cannot speak for themselves.
Recent memory provides me with far too many examples of traumatized victims, each one seared into my brain with excruciating detail. Animals and their people clinging to rooftops after Hurricane Katrina… dogs being hauled away after fighting rings are exposed… horses receiving emergency care after being shot by kids on a nasty “joy ride”…. With any luck, and hopefully some incredibly patient, devoted, and skilled human intervention, some of these victims will become resilient survivors who can go on to live full lives.
However, let us not lose sight of the fact that trauma changes those who experience it on a fundamental, cellular level. Healing the physical wounds is only half the battle – and with survivors who can’t talk, healing the emotional wounds is especially tricky.
Emotional wounds for animals, like with people, tend to play out behaviorally – and so many of use who rescue animals find ourselves working with complicated behavioral puzzles with no clear solutions. Be cautious of those who portend to have a fool-proof way of fixing an animal’s behavior problem, and run in the other direction when they tell you that _________ (insert chosen snake oil here) is the secret to healing a broken spirit.
Truth be told, it’s not love, or a particular training method, or a specific supplement, that resolves the experience of being abused, abandoned, or broken. As with humans, healing the hurt is a much more complicated job.
Sometimes our best hope is to help our animals learn how to live each day safer than the last, or to appreciate what it feels like to be touched by a kind and gentle human hand. And these gains, however small they may seem, are bigger and grander than the love that inspires them.
Read Jeannine's article, Do Pets Show Post-Traumatic Stress?
Jeannine Moga, MA, MSW, LICSW is a social worker and human-animal bond specialist at the University of Minnesota Veterinary Medical Center, and an editorial advisory board member for Star Tribune Pet Central. www.cvm.umn.edu/vmc/aboutvmc/clientsupport.html





Comments
I recently learned an
I recently learned an important lesson, though I am not yet completely sure what that lesson is. I am a staunch supporter of rescuing dogs and cats and am opposed to killing animals for behavioral problems. But, a foster dog that appeared to be very sweet that was very friendly to all he met, seriously bit a visitor to our home without any obvious provocation, though I am sure he had his reasons. I am confused as to whether that dog should indeed be rescued now that he has bitten someone. There have been many theories as to why the bite happened, but does any potential trigger excuse the act or provide reassurance that this dog can be "fixed" and safely adopted? Should time and resources be put toward other dogs instead? Would anyone really want to adopt a dog who has bitten someone? Although I know that many rescued animals are safely placed in homes, I now realize first hand how risky taking a dog with an unknown background into one's home can be. Clearly, it does take more than love to heal wounds.
Dear Confused -- It sounds
Dear Confused --
It sounds like you've got a very difficult situation on your hands. Bites happen for any number of reasons, and they are always quite troubling. It is important that this particular dog be evaluated behaviorally, if possible, to determine what may have contributed to the bite incident and to reduce the risk of another bite occurring.
Dogs with bite histories can be very difficult to safely place in a permanent home, and people who choose to keep such dogs often also have to accept an increasing amount of legal liability for that choice. It is not a dog's fault that these things happen (it is not a "choice" to bite, but an impulsive behavior based on any number of factors) -- and yet we also have to be very aware that dogs cannot always control this impulse.
I believe it is our responsibility as a guardian (even in a foster situation) to provide each dog with every chance to succeed. As such, our response to these kinds of situations is quite important and must be very careful and compassionate. Not every home is best suited to take on special needs and elevated risks, and that is okay. Please make sure you are keeping all of the members of your household safe. I encourage you to work with the rescue organization for whom you foster to determine the best "next steps" for this critter.
Good luck!
Of course resources should
Of course resources should be put toward rehabilitating a rescued dog even though he may have bitten someone. His need for love and rehabilitation are still just as great. All animals deserve a loving home that will address their needs, where their human companions will hear their voice even when the words are unspoken.
It is more challenging to work with an animal that has behavioral issues but he deserves the opportunity (with a devoted human) to try to create emotional balance and stability in his life.
Keep trying! You will both grow and hopefully you will both win from the experience of working together.
Valerie
Behavioral issues are one
Behavioral issues are one thing, but seeing a seemingly sweet, friendly dog rip someone's arm open for no apparent reason is another. People come first. I'm not going to put my family, friends, neighbors or strangers visiting my home at risk for the sake of a dog. I am forever changed. The dog has been returned to the rescue organization for further assessment. I tend to disagree that this dog is adoptable. I think biting is a choice a dog makes on some level. Most dogs never bite. He did not just snap or bite someone's ankle - he jumped up and viciously bit someone, requiring a trip to the emergency room. Due to this unfortunate incident, my foster days are over. The risks, financial and otherwise are too great. I don't think it will be easy to find a home for a dog that has bitten someone. Why would anyone choose a dog with that history when there are so many dogs available?
I'm sorry the incident was
I'm sorry the incident was so traumatic. Fostering animals is a challenge and a many of those animals have been abused and have behaviorial issues. It's good that you were willing to try.
Hopefully the dog in question will find the help he needs.
Unfortunately, this
Unfortunately, this experience made me very untrusting of rescue groups. They have no liability for these dogs' actions. That burden is on the foster family. I was not given information that the dog had previously shown aggression. Of course, dogs are unpredictable, but rescue organizations have a duty to disclose everything about the dogs to foster families who are willing to take responsibility, financial and otherwise, for these dogs. I would recommend that anyone fostering dogs ask a lot of questions and get copies of all paperwork and medical records before agreeing to take the dog home.
I just got a 3month old
I just got a 3month old maltese puppy, it was born without
eyes. People have felt sorry for it ,so all it knows is to be
held, I want to train it as normal as possible, any suggestions would be welcome.
Thanks Fran
Just want to say that rescue
Just want to say that rescue groups and foster parents are wonderful, giving people. They work very hard, and the work is very hard. They do very important work. The foster experience is incredibly rewarding. I would encourage others to volunteer. Just be careful and communicate well. Dogs can be unpredictable, but most of the time the unpredicable thing is that, despite mistreatment and abandonment, they are more wonderful than you can believe. This dog is a sweet, loving pup. I'm glad that he's getting a chance and very much hope he finds a loving home. I appreciate the commitment to him, but worry that the mistake will hurt his chances. I think that he deserves a chance. Thank you to all who rescue. You are my heros.
Post new comment